February
26, 2005, Haiti –
If Haitians were to acknowledge every
governmental transition since the country's
independence, there would be lots of holidays.
In just the last two decades there have been
more than 10 governments, some lasting days,
others years. As we approach, the one-year
anniversary of former president Jean Bertrand
Aristide's Feb. 29 departure, it seems that a
sad pattern of Haiti's history has repeated
itself.
Instead of bringing positive change, as many had
hoped, Aristide's exit has instead left the vast
majority of the population just as unemployed,
uneducated, exploited and invisible as before.
Aristide's exile
was the culmination of months of unrest,
protests and violence, propelled by a gang of
Haitian armed rebels from the Dominican Republic
and what some said was a push -- others a snatch
-- by the U.S. government. Those of us who
witnessed the chaos, fear and turmoil that
precipitated his departure knew just how
fractured, unwieldy and frightening Haiti had
become. So it was no surprise, except perhaps to
the United States, that today Haiti is as
dangerous, unruly and ungovernable as ever. As
has been the case with international
interference in Haitian affairs, there was no
thoughtful game plan for its future, just a
knee-jerk reaction to a very dicey situation.
As with everything
that happens in Haiti, there is no shortage of
theories, conspiracies and rumors to explain why
things aren't going well. And in Haiti, which is
truly a confusing country, things are never as
they seem. There are the obvious factors that
have contributed to the country's current state
-- illiteracy, poverty, drug-trafficking,
corruption and a lack of infrastructure from
which to work.
But scratch below
the surface and things become more complicated
because, despite the laundry list of negatives,
the majority of the population somehow manages
to survive another day with no reliable
resources even as the changes in government come
and go.
`The Turtle'
The current prime
minister, a Haitian technocrat plucked from the
States, has lots of connections to the
international community but none to the Haitian
people. Gerald Latortue, ''The Turtle,'' made
costly errors early on. He embraced thugs whom
he thought he could control, while actively
targeting former Aristide supporters.
High-profile
prisoners, such as Aristide's former prime
minister and his former interior minister have
been in jail for nearly a year with no trial
date in sight. A well-organized jailbreak on
Feb. 19 freed about 500 of the 1,257 prisoners
in the National Penitentiary, 95 percent of whom
have been neither tried nor sentenced. If this
incident is handled like other lawless acts, it
will receive media attention for a nanosecond
and then be tucked away until it becomes
politically advantageous to be exploited again.
U.S. leaders had
hoped that a strong international presence, from
which they lobbied to be excluded almost
completely, could keep things in order. That
hasn't worked, either. More than 250 people have
been killed in the last few months despite the
presence of 6,000 blue-bereted peacekeepers from
the United Nations and 1,400 international
police.
The problem is
that there are as many guns as there are flies
on the street. Those least equipped are the
paltry Haitian police, an under-staffed,
under-trained, corruptible and frightened group
of several thousand.
Then there are the
former Haitian soldiers, whose demands to be
reinstated in the defunct Haitian army have won
them 10 years in back pay and increasing
visibility. Renegades from the police have
joined up with armed supporters of Aristide who
seek his return, and they have launched
''Operation Baghdad,'' engaging in a gruesome
series of beheadings. Nearly a dozen
neighborhoods in Port-au-Prince are under
control of these rebel factions, and at least
five towns across the country are under control
of the former military.
It's alleged that
drug money helps fuel the rebel factions.
Meanwhile, the government has received only 10
percent of the $1.4 billion pledged by the
international community shortly after Aristide's
departure. The international community wants to
see stability before it invests in Haiti, but
the government argues that without adequate
funds stability is impossible.
Coincidentally,
this argument parrots Aristide's denunciation of
the international community, which he blamed for
strangling his efforts to ensure Haiti's
stability and progress.
Do elections,
scheduled for this winter, have any chance of
success? Some 100 candidates hope to be
inaugurated as president on Feb. 7, 2006, the
20th anniversary of the fall of the Duvalier
dictatorship.
I'm sure that few,
if any of them, have a blueprint for how to fix
the mess that Haiti has become. Unless there's
an incentive to bring together the fractured
power-driven groups in Haiti and an unwavering
financial and moral commitment from the
international community, it's safe to say that
with just a few editorial adjustments, this
column could run again next year, same time,
same place.
Kathie
Klarreich, author of a forthcoming memoir on
Haiti, Madame Dread, has lived in and
covered Haiti for nearly 20 years.